Bought a new stove, salvaged some parts in hopes of helping someone out. This element was hard to track down in Canada; looks like it goes for around $50 plus shipping. This one works fine, no problems.
Here's some info I found online about it:
http://www.partselect.ca/PS11747122-Whirlpool-WP9750967-Dual-Broil-Element.htm?SourceCode=3&SearchTerm=9750967